SoA Forums

General Category => Army Research => Topic started by: Swampster on October 01, 2024, 03:28:09 PM

Title: Medieval Cuneus
Post by: Swampster on October 01, 2024, 03:28:09 PM
I've just been reading a recent book on Montaperti. Regarding the Germans, the author quotes
"et hinc in partis cuneis militum... aquilarum victricium insignis explicati, invocata sublimi glorisi Dei iustitia... nec non fortuna regia que conterendam rebellium suorum potentiam depressit, ubique initium est prelium et multorum generale periculo" (Lectere debelationis populi florentini Bib Ap Vat Ott. Lat. 1101)
which is apparently by a Pisan supporter of Manfred soon after the battle.

Is the cuneus literally a wedge? I have an idea that it could just be a solid body of troops. There is reference to the cuneus Francorum at Poitiers. Are there any other High medieval uses which clarify?

Cheers
P
Title: Re: Medieval Cuneus
Post by: Erpingham on October 01, 2024, 03:47:36 PM
It is, of course, famously used of English archers at Agincourt.  Much has been written about whether it is meant literally as "wedge".  However, the usual medieval meaning seems to have been "body of troops".  As Matt Bennett long ago pointed out, the same source which uses cuneus for English archers also uses it for French forces a few lines previously. 
Title: Re: Medieval Cuneus
Post by: Bohemond on October 15, 2024, 01:00:07 PM
An argument to which I still adhere! I absolutely agree with Swampster on the matter.
Title: Re: Medieval Cuneus
Post by: Andreas Johansson on October 15, 2024, 02:01:34 PM
FWIW, the Dictionary of Medieval Latin (https://mlw.badw.de/en/mlw-digital.html) thinks it can mean both a specifically wedge-shaped formation (keilförmige Schlachtreihe, -ordnung) and simply a body of troops (Heerschar, Haufen).

(Note: the Dictionary is specifically concerned with Latin usage in German-speaking Europe during the Early and High Middle Ages. It does however also draw words and examples from Frankish/French and Italian works that are relevant to German history, so your Florentine example is at least within its penumbra.)
Title: Re: Medieval Cuneus
Post by: Erpingham on October 15, 2024, 02:28:16 PM
The Dictionary of Medieval Latin from Medieval Sources (DBLMS) comes to a similar conclusion. It appears that when applied to soldiers or animals it meant foremost "group or body", with the shape secondary.