News:

Welcome to the SoA Forum.  You are welcome to browse through and contribute to the Forums listed below.

Main Menu

Did the Beaker Folk wipe out the Stonehenge-builders?

Started by Duncan Head, May 22, 2017, 09:38:40 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Duncan Head

Genetic evidence suggests that the people who built Stonehenge left no trace on the genome of subsequent British populations:
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/may/20/dutch-invaders-stonehenge-ancient-britons

Of course, maybe Stonehenge was a portal to another dimension, and the continental incomers just occupied the space that the vanished henge-builders left empty.

Or maybe the sample set is just too small.
Duncan Head

Imperial Dave

not sure Duncan, the piece is not specific in terms of where they tested the DNA samples from. Were they just in the Wiltshire area or throughout the UK? As you point out there is no indication of the sample size for the UK analysis. It would seem very odd to have one culture/genetically unique grouping completely replace another.

Even the Neanderthals appear to have left some DNA hanging around in the modern gene pool. If the normal pattern of 'invasion' occurs then the preceding groupings normally move West and North and we should be able to find some evidence there...?
Slingshot Editor

Duncan Head

The http://biorxiv.org page linked to has a "Supplementary Information" tab which gives info on where some of the samples came from, but it's samples from all over Europe and I'm not interested enough to go through it looking for the British ones.
Duncan Head

Dave Beatty

Weren't there some mass graves found in Wiltshire that were associated with a violent demise of the indigenous folk and posited to be the outcome of a battle with the invading Bronze Age Beaker Folk? Maybe I am getting my prehistoric massacres mixed up...